Jeffers Top 5 Best Selling Cat Toys

What do you get the finicky feline who is hard to please? At Jeffers, we know that finding a toy that keeps your cat occupied can sometimes be a challenge. Thankfully, we’ve compiled a list of our fan-favorite, best selling cat toys to help make things a little bit easier.

Not sure where to start? Keep scrolling for tried and true toys that make cats and customers happy. Whether you have a new kitten or a seasoned mouser, these toys will hopefully get them pouncing and chirping away!

1.) Pawbreakers! Catnip Toy
A compressed ball of 100% pure catnip, this ball for cats is utterly irresistible to those catnip-lovers. Approximately 1.25 inches in diameter, it is just the perfect size for curious cats. Plus, it’s made in the USA without preservatives, colors, or flavoring. This budget-friendly toy serves double duty as it also makes an excellent treat for cats. A few reviewers couldn’t even get the Pawbreaker out of its packaging before the cats were all over it! With over 1,000 sold in 2020, it’s not hard to see why this is at the top of our best selling cat toys list.

2.) Jeffers Jingle Balls, 4-Pack
From batting it off the couch to rolling around on the floor with it, there’s something about a jingle ball that is truly irresistible to cats. The jingle bell comes enclosed in a round plastic basket with the bell visible for a truly tantalizing time. While some cats may find just a plain wool or plastic ball interesting enough, the added bell takes things up a notch increasing interest and providing more stimulation. With each bat the ball jingles, which drives your cat to keep batting to get that little noise out of it.

3.) Rosie Rat
Keep your feline entertained for hours with this customer-favorite Rosie Rat cat toy. This cat-approved toy features a flat, fuzzy body and a soft suede leather head and tail. They’ll love to pounce and bat this little creature across the floor as if it were real (without the headache for you.) One customer shares that her rescue cat didn’t play much before purchasing Rosie and now runs and jumps in the air! Another customer, KW, even mentions that her cat brings this mouse cat toy to bed every morning to wake her up – now that’s love!

4.) Mylar Crackle Balls, 4-Pack
With a crinkle sound and texture cats can’t resist, these crackle balls are a cat and customer favorite. Great for cats of all ages, mylar crackle balls appeal to many of your cat’s senses and natural instincts with their shiny look, crinkly texture, and lightweight ball shape. It’s a great option to help satisfy your cat’s urge to hunt, swat, and play. One customer review says their kittens will play “kitty soccer” with the crackle balls and carry them around in their mouth. With so many different ways to play, these crackle balls are sure to be your cat’s new favorite toy.

5.) Da Bird Teaser Wand
From the original and unique cat toy creators, Da Bird Teaser Wand activates your cat’s hunting instincts with real bird noises and motions that your cats just can’t resist. Drag this over the carpet and into the air and watch them leap! Da Bird wand is clearly one of our customers’ favorites with its sturdy wire and tantalizing feathers. And fear not, when those feathers are threadbare from use, easily replace with a refill feather to keep the game going. If you and your cat are already familiar with Da Bird, find more Go Cat toys to keep things interesting and exciting. While this product is more expensive than the others on our list, in just 2 years, it has quickly broken into our Top 5 best selling cat toys and is sure to keep climbing.

What if My Cat Doesn’t Like Toys?

If your cat isn’t big on toy-based play, try encouraging exercise by offering them treats. Pop’N Bites, Jeffers best-selling cat treat, offers seafood-flavored deliciousness at an affordable price. Each treat features a fun fish shape and a crunchy texture that gets most cats hooked!

No matter how your cat likes to play, Jeffers offers a variety of products that fit your cat’s needs. Click to shop Jeffers full selection of cat toys or all cat treats.

Need Advice? Contact Us For All Your Cat Needs!

If you’re looking for a different toy for your cat, or need help finding the perfect treat, just reach out! Feel free to email us or call 1-800-533-3377. Our friendly team of customer service representatives are happy to help.

The information given is meant to be helpful and/or educational. It is, in no way intended to supersede, challenge, or supplant the diagnosis, treatment, or advice of a licensed veterinarian.

Have a multi-pet household? Check out our Jeffers Top 5 Best Selling Dog Products: Toys and Treats.